Validation SOPs › Business Model Validation

SOP 54 of 100 · Business Model Validation

Value Chain Analysis SOP

In short: Map every activity between your first supplier and a satisfied customer, put a quoted cost and a customer-rated value on each, and decide what to own, outsource or cut. The chain passes when written quotes confirm the gross margin in your model within 10% and you can name at least one activity where you beat rivals on cost or quality.
Difficulty
Advanced
Time
1 week of mapping, 1-2 weeks of supplier quotes
Cost
$0-300
Best for
Physical products, marketplaces and service businesses that depend on suppliers
Tools
Miro, Google Sheets, Lucidchart, Alibaba, LinkedIn
Measure
Cost share per activity, Gross margin per order, Supplier concentration, Activities where you beat rivals

A value chain analysis shows every step your product passes through before a customer pays for it, what each step costs and which steps customers actually care about. For a founder it answers two hard questions in one to three weeks: where does the margin leak, and where can you be better than anyone else? The output is a costed map, written supplier quotes and a decision on what you build in-house, what you buy and what you drop.

What is the value chain analysis SOP and when should you use it?

Michael Porter introduced the value chain in his book Competitive Advantage. He split a company's work into five activities that touch the product directly (inbound logistics, operations, outbound logistics, marketing and sales, and service) and four support activities (firm infrastructure, human resource management, technology development and procurement). Margin is what remains after all nine are paid for. Porter's point for strategy: advantage comes from doing specific activities cheaper or better than rivals, so you need to see each activity separately.

Use this SOP:

  • Before you sign with a manufacturer, warehouse or agency, while you can still change who does what.
  • When your gross margin looks thin and you can't see which step eats it.
  • When a competitor sells the same thing cheaper and you need to know whether they buy, make or ship differently.
  • Before you raise money, because investors ask which part of the chain you control.

This SOP looks at activities in sequence. A view of fixed versus variable costs for the whole company belongs to the cost structure validation SOP, and the margin on one order or customer is the job of the unit economics validation SOP.

What do you need before you start?

  • A clear product and price, even a target price from a pre-order or survey.
  • Your expected order volume for the first 12 months, because supplier prices depend on it.
  • Notes from 10 or more customer interviews, so you can rate which steps customers notice.
  • A whiteboard tool such as Miro or Lucidchart and a spreadsheet.
  • A list of 3 candidate suppliers per input, found through trade directories, Alibaba, LinkedIn or industry fairs.

How do you run it, step by step?

1. Draw the chain from first input to after-sale

Write every activity in order, from buying raw inputs to handling returns and support. Use Porter's five direct activities as columns and add the support activities underneath. Be literal: "pack order in recycled mailer" beats "fulfilment". Most startup chains have 10 to 20 activities.

2. Mark who performs each activity

Tag each activity as you, a supplier, a partner or the customer. Customers doing work (assembly, self-service setup) is a legitimate design choice, and IKEA built a business on flat-pack furniture that buyers carry home and assemble themselves. Seeing the tags side by side shows how much of the chain you depend on others for.

3. Put a cost per order on each activity

Convert every cost into a figure per order or per unit: supplier quotes, shipping rates, payment fees, packaging, minutes of your own time. Use written quotes where you can and mark guesses in a different colour. Add a column for each activity's share of total cost.

4. Rate what each activity is worth to the customer

Score each activity from 1 to 5 on how much customers notice or care, using interview notes as evidence. A test question for each one: would a customer complain or leave if this step got worse? Fast shipping, packaging and support speed score very differently across markets, so let your interviews decide.

5. Test your suppliers

For every outside input, collect three quotes, minimum order quantities, lead times and payment terms. Flag any input with a single possible supplier, and any supplier that would hold more than half of your cost. Ask each one what happens to price at 3 times your volume.

6. Find the leaks and the edge

Plot activities on two axes: share of cost and customer value. High cost with low customer value is a leak: renegotiate, outsource or remove it. High customer value where you can do better than rivals is your edge: keep it in-house and invest there. Compare against two competitors where their choices are visible (shipping times, packaging, support channels).

7. Write the chain decision memo

One page: the costed chain, confirmed gross margin per order, own/outsource/cut decisions for each activity, supplier risks and the one or two activities where you lead. Revisit it whenever volume triples or a supplier changes terms.

Template you can copy

ActivityGroup (direct or support)Done byCost per order $Share of cost %Customer value 1-5EvidenceRival comparisonDecision (own / outsource / cut)Risk notes
Buy raw inputsDirect: inbound logisticsSupplier AQuote dated …Single source?
Make or assembleDirect: operations
Pack and shipDirect: outbound logistics
Sell and advertiseDirect: marketing and sales
Support and returnsDirect: service
Product and tech workSupport: technology development
Buying and contractsSupport: procurement
Total100%

Worked example: refillable cleaning products sold online

This is an illustrative case with invented figures. A founder sells a starter kit of plant-based cleaning concentrates for $24. Her first costed chain looks like this per order:

ActivityCost per orderCustomer value (from 14 interviews)
Concentrate from supplier$3.105
Glass bottles$2.403
Filling and labelling (her own studio)$1.804
Warehouse picking and packing (outsourced)$4.202
Next-day shipping$5.502
Payment fees$0.951
Support and returns$1.053
Total$19.00

Gross margin is $5, or 21%. Picking, packing and shipping take $9.70, which is 51% of cost, while customers rate both steps a 2. The interviews show customers care about the refill subscription and the scent, and nobody needs next-day delivery for cleaning spray.

She swaps glass bottles in refill orders for letterbox-sized pouches ($1.20), moves to standard post ($2.90) and gets a cheaper packing rate for flat parcels ($2.60). New cost: $13.60, margin 43%. Filling stays in-house because the scent blends are her edge.

What should you measure, and when do you stop?

MetricPass signalWarning signal
Cost share per activityNo single low-value activity above 20% of costOne activity customers barely notice eats a quarter or more
Gross margin per orderWritten quotes confirm your model within 10%Quotes land more than 10% below your model
Supplier concentration2+ qualified suppliers for every inputOne supplier for an input you can't replace within a month
Activities where you beat rivalsAt least 1 activity with evidence you do it cheaper or betterYou do every activity the same way competitors do

Stop when every activity has a written cost, every outside input has at least two quotes, and the margin holds at your 12-month volume. If the margin only works at a volume you can't reach in the first year, the chain fails at today's scale and needs a redesign before launch.

Which mistakes should you avoid?

  • Mapping only the steps you do yourself. Supplier and shipping steps hide most of the cost in product businesses.
  • Using list prices instead of quotes. Ask for prices at your real volume; small orders pay more per unit.
  • Rating customer value from your own taste. Score each step from interview evidence, or you protect the parts you enjoy.
  • Outsourcing your edge. If your advantage is the formula, the curation or the service, keep it in-house even when a supplier quotes less.
  • Ignoring returns and support. They come last in the chain and first in angry reviews.

How can AI speed this up?

Paste your product description into an AI assistant and ask for a first draft of the chain with Porter's activities as headings; it lists steps you forgot, such as quality checks and returns handling. It can also draft supplier request-for-quote emails and turn messy quote PDFs into rows for your sheet. Every cost figure an AI suggests is a placeholder until a supplier confirms it in writing, and the customer value scores must come from your interviews.

To see how the chain fits the rest of your model, the business model canvas generator turns your activities, partners and costs into a one-page canvas.

Where does this SOP fit in your validation plan?

Run it after you know your customer and price, and before you commit to suppliers or partners.

  1. Check that the whole model hangs together with the business model canvas validation SOP.
  2. Turn the costed chain into margin per order with the unit economics validation SOP.
  3. Test resellers and distributors that sit at the end of the chain with the channel partner validation SOP.
  4. Use your edge in the market story through competitive positioning analysis.
  5. Check what breaks at higher volume with the scalability testing SOP.

Browse the full set of Business Model Validation SOPs. A free SWOT analysis generator helps you write up the strengths and supplier threats you found.

FAQ

What are the steps of a value chain analysis?

List every activity from inputs to after-sale service, assign who does each one, cost each per order, rate customer value, test suppliers, then decide what to own, outsource or cut.

What is the difference between a value chain and a supply chain?

A supply chain covers the flow of goods from suppliers to you and on to customers. A value chain adds everything you do to create value, including marketing, sales, service and technology work, and asks where margin comes from.

Is value chain analysis useful for software startups?

Yes, with different activities: hosting, third-party APIs, support, sales and content. The leak in software tends to sit in sales and support time instead of shipping.

How detailed should my value chain be?

Detailed enough that each activity has one owner and one cost per order. For most early startups that means 10 to 20 rows.